Where art thou, S'pore hunks?
Are China-born hunks hotter than local heart-throbs? Viewers say what they think as the three male leads on Channel 8 drama Together battle it out
DAI Yangtian, Zhang Zhenhuan and Elvin Ng.
Proof? All three snagged the male lead roles in the current Channel 8 blockbuster drama series Together.
We may be a small nation, but really, just three to feed the appetite of more than a million female TV viewers in Singapore?
Among these slim pickings, two are foreign talents from China: Shanghai-born Yangtian, 25, and Sichuan-born Zhenhuan, 24 - the latter touted to be the next big thing by industry insiders.
Where are the Singaporean heart-throbs?
More importantly, what's so appealing about these China-born dudes?
Student Lena Goh, 17, said: 'Elvin is our only 'local hope' left in terms of young male celebrities.'
Fashion designer Low Ai Ling, 35, said the foreigners are better-looking. She told The New Paper: 'I think the China boys are more suave. Yangtian is the hottest as he just oozes sex appeal. Perhaps it's his low voice and good command of Mandarin as well. '
Accounts executive Jolene Soh, 32, thinks nationality doesn't matter, though she has a soft spot for Zhenhuan.
'Mandarin is their weakness'
She said: 'Zhenhuan stands out because he has a baby face. It's my bet that Zhenhuan may have started out the slowest but he will last the longest.'
But not all think the mainland Chinese actors are better.
While student Gwendolyn Tan, 21, thinks Yangtian is good-looking, it's 29-year-old Elvin that gets her weak in the knees.
'He's very personable, while Yangtian appears cool and aloof,' she explained.
Yesteryear homegrown idol Thomas Ong said: 'The China-born artistes are good-looking because the country has a big population and we can select the cream of the crop.'
Fellow man-hunk Tay Ping Hui said that he was impressed by Zhenhuan's work ethic.
'He's very hardworking and has the right attitude. He just needs the experience.'
We asked Elvin, Yangtian and Zhenhuan to compare who's the hottest among them.
The trio, however, diligently maintained good Sino-Singapore relations (that's PR-speak for politically-correct answers).
'The three of us appeal to different people so I can't say who is better,' Yangtian said.
'Elvin has the Pan-Asian look and I have the Taiwanese idol look. Zhenhuan has the Japanese idol look - he has extremely attractive eyes. If I were a girl I would be 'struck' by them.'
Competition
But Elvin said that although there's 'fair and healthy competition' among them, he feels that local artistes should get more support from Singaporeans.
He added: 'There seems to be this post-colonial complex where anything foreign is perceived as better.
'What we bring to the table that China-born artistes can't is that we are definitely closer to the local heart. For example, in Together, watching China-born artistes telling us about Singapore's history is a bit strange.'
Okay, but if Singaporeans are to support local artistes, there must first be talent for us to rave about.
Which brings us back to the first question - why is there such a dearth of young Singaporean heart-throbs?
To think that a generation ago, home-grown Mandarin-speaking hunks like Thomas Ong, Terence Cao, Edmund Chen and Tay Ping Hui were the talk of the town.
Their immediate successors included the likes of Vincent Ng, Ix Shen, Julian Hee and Adam Chen, who failed to hit the big time.
Which brings us to the tragic present, where Elvin appears to be, to put it bluntly, the best of what's left.
Perhaps he hit the nail on the head with a recent blog entry.
He wrote: 'Do you want to be a small fish in a big pond? Or a big fish in a small pond?
'So the next time you see me, don't ask me why Singaporean actors cannot compete with Hong Kong actors or cannot break into the Hong Kong market, and why Hong Kong actors cannot then easily break into Hollywood.'
But hold it before you begin to think our island is devoid of good-looking men.
Said Zhenhuan: 'When I modelled here, I saw some really good-looking Singaporean men but their biggest weakness is their limited spoken Mandarin.'
Local Mandarin dramas draw the biggest audiences on free-to-air channels here. Even non-Mandarin-speaking actor-hosts like Adrian Pang and Gurmit Singh - regular fixtures on Channel 5 - have crossed over to Channel 8.
Zhenhuan gave the example of a 26-year-old local banker and part-time actor who has a small role in the latest Channel 8 drama, New Beginnings.
'He's interested in acting but he said he can't join the industry because his Mandarin isn't good.'
Yangtian also agreed that China artistes have Mandarin as an advantage compared to Singaporean artistes. That could have been 25-year-old Nat Ho's Achilles' heel.
Once considered a prime candidate with lots of potential, his standing in popularity has wavered since he signed on with MediaCorp as a full-time artiste in 2006. But viewer Miss Tan feels language has nothing to do with it.
'Regardless, Singaporean actors are like limited-edition stars: they are popular only for a short period of time.'
No comments:
Post a Comment